Custom Search

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Stimulus Package: Does It Even Work?



The government mailed out the long awaited rebates. The current debate is about how big of an impact these rebates will have on the economy and when. The clear assumption is that the stimulus package is GUARANTEED to work and it is only a question of degree.

What we need is to take a look at similar countries in similar situations to see how things turned out in practice, rather than in theory.

If only we could turn to a country that had both a MASSIVE real estate bubble and credit bubble simultaneously…

If only we could turn to a country that had similar demographics, namely a large portion of the workforce nearing retirement…

If only we could turn to a country whose monetary authorities responded with massive rate cuts, liquidity injections, tax cuts and stimulus packages…

Oh wait, I got one. Can you say JAPAN?

An Overview of Japan's Economy 1985–2000

After the September 1985 Plaza Accord, the yen's appreciation hit the export sector hard, reducing economic growth from 4.4 percent in 1985 to 2.9 percent in 1986 (EIU 2001).1 The government attempted to offset the stronger yen by drastically easing monetary policy between January 1986 and February 1987. During this period, the Bank of Japan (BOJ) cut the discount rate in half from 5 percent to 2.5 percent. Following the economic stimulus, asset prices in the real estate and stock markets inflated, creating one of the biggest financial bubbles in history. The government responded by tightening monetary policy, raising rates five times, to 6 percent in 1989 and 1990. After these increases, the market collapsed.

The Nikkei stock market index fell more than 60 percent—from a high of 40,000 at the end of 1989 to under 15,000 by 1992. It rose somewhat during the mid-1990s on hopes that the economy would soon recover, but as the economic outlook continued to worsen, share prices again fell. The Nikkei fell below 12,000 by March 2001. Real estate prices also plummeted during the recession—by 80 percent from 1991 to 1998 (Herbener 1999).

Real GDP during the 1990s stagnated, rising only from 428,826 billion yen in 1990 to 469,480 billion yen by the end of 2000.2 Growth has been negative since 1998. The unemployment rate rose from 2.1 percent in 1991 to 4.7 percent at the end of 2000. Although the unemployment rate may seem low by international standards, the rise to 4.7 percent is significant in Japan, given the cultural and historical precedent of lifetime employment and given that it was never above 2.8 percent in the 1980s. The official unemployment rate is also biased downward because the Japanese government offers "employment adjustment subsidies" to companies that maintain employees as "window sitters" (Herbener 1999).

The Response 1992-1995

Between 1992 and 1995, Japan tried six spending programs totaling 65.5 trillion yen and cut income tax rates during 1994. In January 1998, Japan temporarily cut taxes again by 2 trillion yen. Then, in April of that year, the government unveiled a fiscal stimulus package worth more than 16.7 trillion yen, almost half of which was for public works. Again, in November 1998, another fiscal stimulus package worth 23.9 trillion yen was announced. A year later (November 1999), yet another fiscal stimulus package of 18 trillion yen was tried. Finally, in October 2000, Japan announced yet another fiscal stimulus package of 11 trillion yen. Overall during the 1990s, Japan tried 10 fiscal stimulus packages totaling more than 100 trillion yen, and each failed to cure the recession. What the spending programs have done, however, is put Japan's government in poor fiscal shape. The "on-budget" government spending has caused public debt to exceed 100 percent of GDP (highest in the G7), and even more debt is apparent when the "off-budget" sector is included.

The Keynesian policy solution when the economy is in a liquidity trap is to have the government lend directly to businesses instead of creating liquidity in the banking system. Japan has the Fiscal Investment and Loan Programme (FILP), an off-budget branch of the Japanese government worth about 70 percent of the spending in the general-account budget. FILP gets most of its money from the post office savings accounts. Once they collect the money, the funds are allocated to borrowers through the Ministry of Finance Trust Fund Bureau and the bureau's various agencies. Much of this money is not allocated to the most efficient projects.

Politicians in the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) run most of these government agencies. The Economist Intelligence Unit profile states that "FILP money is channeled toward traditional supporters of the LDP, such as those in the construction industry, and without proper consideration of the costs and benefits of specific projects" (EIU 2001, p. 30). Although this Keynesian approach of government direct-lending does avoid the reluctance of banks to lend, it does not aid economy recovery. Funds are not allocated according to market-based consumer preferences, but to the most politically connected businessmen. This leads to a higher cost of borrowing for those seeking private funds, further distorting the economy. Also, because the loans are often highly risky, Japan's fiscal condition deteriorates further. Once FILP and other "off-budget" debts are included, Japan's debt is estimated to exceed 200 percent of GDP (EIU 2001).

Read the full article here: Explaining Japan’s Recession

In the end it all didn’t work. The agony was prolonged and is now referred to as the Lost Decade in Japan.

Sparked by low interest rates, Japans average home value more than doubled from the early 1980's to 1990 (sound familiar?). Now, over 16 years after prices peaked, home values are still declining and are nearing the average price of 1980.

The situation in Japan then and America now are eerily similar. I would argue that America is actually worse off. The ABSOLUTE lack of personal savings is really going to hurt the team here.

I’m with Mish on this one: Stimulus Checks Already Spent

Related Posts:
Fact Sheet: The Bush Stimulus Package

30 comments:

Anonymous said...

Lack of saving?? We are not just lack of saving, we have negative saving rate!! We do better, we rack up debt!! Our economy is propt up by debt. Citizen keep on borrowing money to spend to keep economy going!

Anonymous said...

Add that Japan fiscal stimuli were marginally productive in the sense that they were used to build infrastructures.

The consumer-centric US stimulus is INTENDED to just be spent, possibly buying the last "made in china" useless item or paying for the last dinner out.

I can't figure out how people can hope for a rebound in the economy coming from one last dinner out!

Ben Bittrolff said...

Alessandro,

Well put.
One last dinner out.
We'll worry about the hangover later.

Anonymous said...

baskets puma future cat low engine noirBon March¨¦ Chaussure Sports Shop:puma future low catChaussure Puma Femme,Chaussure Puma Homme,Chaussure Nike Femme,Chaussure Nike homme,future cat low engineChaussure Sport et plus. Livraison Rapide.Paypal

Anonymous said...

I like your blog . They are really great. Ermunterung ++ .please pay a return visit to my blog .thank you.
http://blog.goo.ne.jp/iblog99/
http://iblog99.easyjournal.com/
http://iblog99.blogger.de/

kinggool said...

Interesting blog on Japan! I know of a great website which sells fashionable apparel online. With attractive and stylish designs, this site showcases designer products that possess impeccable attention to detail having undergone the most stringent of quality control measures for the perfect fit with materials that do not irritate the skin.

trustme said...

Hello, wonderful blog!thank you. By the way,here we offer a lot of good nike shoes,you can come to have

a look.
nike shox r5
nike air max 180
nike nouvelle
tn chaussures
nike tn
tn chaussures
nike air max
pour nike air max 91
shox oz
MBT
nike nouvelle collection
air max tn
nike air max 97
nike store
nike dunk sb high
nike air max
MBT France
basket nike enfant
tn chaussures
nike air max
enfant chaussures
wholesale nike dunk
achat chaussures nike homme nouvelle collection
air max 91
nouvelle requin tn
nike dunk sb
basket nike shox
nike air max 180
MBT chaussures

wholesale aviator sunglasses said...

In Marketing, you should understand who your target market is. Create one-word adjectives that best describes your target market. For example, you may describe the customers of your classic aviators as "macho" or "rebel" for your polarized wayfarers.

Unknown said...

No matter what product you purchase from us north face jacketsWe are offering you a wide range ofnorth face outletquestion,Some color combinations seem to never get old north face outerwearBut within the same community north face coatsbecause it features just the right amount of north face uk,look at another good paoduct such as Dior totes,A little of these are given below.ugg bootswas a very well-known French fashionable boot
cheap ugg boots,because of the wisdom of brilliant featuresdiscount ugg boots,which you are buying is unique and original classic ugg boots,When possible, they obtain materials from domestic suppliers ugg classic tall boots,which makes it exclusive and unique

ai said...

Nike air jordan 2010
basketball air jordan shoes
cheap jordan shoes outlet
jordan
discount jordan shoes

wholesale designer sunglasses said...

The unemployment rate rose from 2.1 percent in 1991 to 4.7 percent at the end of 2000. Although the unemployment rate may seem low by international standards, the rise to 4.7 percent is significant in Japan, given the cultural and historical precedent of lifetime employment and given that it was never above 2.8 percent in the 1980s.

Anonymous said...

fg

nigel said...

Chosing the right wedding ro engagement gift need not be difficult if you follow these simple tips. http://blog.sidestreetstudio.com/wood/9-tips-for-finding-the-perfect-wedding-gift/

skin care manufacturer said...

FILP gets most of its money from the post office savings accounts. Once they collect the money, the funds are allocated to borrowers through the Ministry of Finance Trust Fund Bureau and the bureau's various agencies.

jansmithxxx said...

Choosing eyeglasses for the children could be fairly hard. Choosing glasses which might be stylish and compliment your child's face is often even tougher. Ray Ban Junior Glasses aim to produce this procedure simpler.Once you search towards the style benefits of Ray Ban 3025 Aviators you are going to find out a classic style which has withstood the test of time and is frequently rising in recognition.Very best of all this style of fashion eye put on has a long background which assists in generating the RayBan aviators one particular of a type on the subject of style.b

Anonymous said...

I like football, prefer the beautiful and stylish football shoes to introduce aNike soccer cleats.
Prefer Nike mercurial vapor superfly

contactos valencia said...

Thanks for your article, really useful information.

Anonymous said...

Leaving a comment is the biggest support to Blogger.Thanks!
buy thomas sabo

Your Escort Agency said...

Your Escort Agency offers exclusive and most beautiful London escort girls of various nationalities.

Everett Jenquin said...

The air max 95 is usually a individual Nike shoe that was initially launched by Nike in 1990 being a important merchandise and some thing which reissued in 2000 on the market being a traditional reissue pair of major operating sneakers. In an effort to preserve capital after you acquire the running shoe along with other womens nike air max 2011 products, it's a good idea that you buy from the seller offers Nike Air Max reductions. mens nike air max 24-7 presents online coupons and savings for all its buyers.

Unknown said...

Mens Moncler sale Vests is the renowned high-end outerwear brand which Moncler Online created a quilted moncler vests trend in the fashion world. Never one to Moncler Outlet Store stand still in time, Moncler has always kept abreast of the latest technologies and stayed true to its origins without compromising its runway worthy style. If it has a Moncler Online Shop, it will keep you warm on top of the highest mountain and be trendy on any city street. More mens Uggs clearance at Uggs nederland for your best choice! ugg australia boots is the most professional down coat in the world.Using the selected materials and sophisticated technology, Ugg outlet store Down Coats have good heat preservation and excellent anti-wind features.All of the mens down coat sale at our moncler outlet store are famous for their high quality and fashion styles.When you were in, you will feel comfortable and will be the fashional guy in the cold winter.Moncler Mens Jackets-many new styles jackets for customers.These jackets are in many colors very stylish and warm.Long coats or short down jackets for men are the perfect option for you.Moncler jacket is your best choice in cold winter.You can have a special feeling while you are wearing it.More the other moncler down jacket,moncler jackets australia at moncler outlet store.

Cheap Soccer Cleats said...

Nike Football Boots
Nike Mercurial Superfly Safari
Nike Mercurial Superfly III
Nike Mercurial Superfly II
Nike Mercurial Superfly V
Nike Mercurial Safari
Nike CTR 360
Nike Total 90
Nike Tiempo
Nike Mercurial TF
Nike Indoor Boots
Nike Mercurial SL

Hermes Handbags said...

Hermes Birkin
Hermes Kelly
Hermes Bangle
Hermes Wallets
Hermes Scarf
Hermes Jypsiere
Hermes Constance
Hermes Victoria
Hermes Lindy

Christian Louboutin Boots said...

Christian Louboutin Flats
Christian Louboutin Mary Jane
Christian Louboutin Peep Toe
Louboutin Pumps
Christian Louboutin Rolando
Christian Louboutin Sneakers
Christian Louboutin Evening
Christian Louboutin Wedges

www.mueblesensevilla.com said...

Thank you for your article, pretty worthwhile material.

ugg boots outlet said...

UGG أستراليا لديه سمعة جيدة لجعل بعض من أفضل حذاء جلد الغنم على هذا الكوكب. أحذيتهم هو أنيق جدا ومتطورة وشعبية.uggs clearance إذا كنت نلقي نظرة في أي مدينة كبيرة في البلاد، وسوف تكون ملزمة لك لرؤية شخص واحد من الأحذية على.uggs clearance تمت كتابة هذا المقال أن ننظر إلى الأحذية لون واحد من هذه الشركة على وجه الخصوص ، Boots.Even UGG الأسود رغم أن هناك العديد من خيارات الألوان المختلفة المتوفرة من الشركة، وأكثرها شيوعا هو UGG بووتس في الأسود. ويمكن عزو هذه الأحذية شعبية جيدة لكيفية ظهورهما على القدمين ، فضلا عن كونها مباراة رائعة لمجموعة واسعة من ملابس. إذا كنت تأخذ أي وقت مضى نظرة على شخص يرتدي تظهر نفسها، ستلاحظ أن تبدو عصرية جدا وأنيقة. هذه الأحذية هي التي تعطي لهم أن الجاذبية المضافة.ugg coupon هي وضعت أحذية سوداء UGG باستخدام أعلى جودة وأفضل الغنم حولها.ugg boots outlet والغنم التي استخدمت في انشاء هذه الأحذية غير المزدوج التي تواجهها. هذه المواد تحتوي على ضعف الجانب الصوف الناعم على جانب واحد من جلد الغزال، من جهة أخرى. هذه المواد عند استخدامها لخلق الأحذية ، والنتائج في التمهيد الذي لينة جدا و<.The التي تم إنشاؤها باستخدام هذا الغنم أرفع دائما مريحة وناعمة ومريحة، ناهيك دائم. والغنم المستخدمة في إنشاء هذا التمهيد ، ويسمح لها الفتيل بعيدا بسهولة الرطوبة. وهذا يعني أن القدمين ستبقى دائما باردة. فهو يساعد أيضا على أن التمهيد للتنفس، وهو ما يعني أن الهواء غير قادرين على التحرك بحرية، مما أدى إلى feet.There جافة ومريحة والعديد من الأساليب المختلفة للأحذية الأسود المتاحة والأمر متروك لكم لاختيار الحذاء الذي هو حق لك.ugg australia uk شيء واحد لا يضمن لك، هو التمهيد مريح ودافئ، وسوداء اللون مذهلة.Cheap Ugg UK هذا هو منتج للغاية وأوصت وأنت لن يندم تملك نفسك الزوج.UGG Outlet Store الحصول على واحد اليومuggs clearance
moncler online shop!

London escorts said...

Bestescort4U agency provids best London escorts companionship in the UK.

Herschel Muehlbach said...

This common Moncler brand name identify includes a very long and even illustrious background. moncler outlet vogue brand name features proven, repeatedly, your real mettle it's on designing materials plus moncler jackets layers which can be exclusive therefore amazing they type typically the one-of-its form style attire. These days, relying around the rate, the moncler outlet italy cover can certainly either come to be created together with affordable, or even by using a blend connected with polyester not to mention plastic.

credit score repair said...

of course the stimulus works it puts money into the incumbent's hand who then gives it to a voter for a vote. Works wonderfully.

www.cantabria-3d.com said...

I found a great deal of useful material here!