Custom Search

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Economic Nuclear Winter

This is a refreshingly blunt and realistic assessment of the global financial situation from China.

I don't even think we can blame the evil Black Swan for this... because it really was entirely predictable AND avoidable.

Nuclear Winter: “The global financial crisis is far from over, and now a global economic crisis seems to be unfolding. Recent economic data suggests that the global economy is decelerating rapidly. Even though the US Congress reluctantly passed the USD 700 billion Wall Street rescue plan, stock markets are already focusing on the economic downside. Many investors are bearish enough to talk about a “nuclear winter” for the global economy. How bad could it be?

The Anglo-Saxon economies will follow a similar pattern to that which East Asian economies experienced a little over a decade ago, when the Asian financial crisis led to a 70-90% drop in asset prices, and a 5-10% contraction in most East Asian economies. Australia, the UK, and the US could contract by 2-5%, only held up by their large service economies and strong social welfare systems.

A contraction of such magnitude for large developed economies has not occurred since the Second World War. Hence, the term “nuclear winter” to describe the coming economic downturn may not be an exaggeration.

Anglo-Saxon economies account for over one-third of the global economy and have been a demand driver through their large current account deficits. Their downturn will drag down their trading partners. The eurozone is already stumbling, as the weak dollar has allowed the US to gain market share against EU exporters, and the unfolding US recession has cut demand for European products in their largest market. This will drive the eurozone, particularly export-reliant Germany, into a recession, with Japan following closely on its heels.

China’s exports will also suffer, possibly going into decline in 2009. China’s exports are 36% of GDP in nominal value and probably 25% of GDP in value added. In previous downturns, China was small and cheap enough to expand its exports through market-share gains, but now, as the largest exporter in the world, there is nowhere left to expand to.

If the property bubble were to burst, as now seems to be happening, its economic impact would be much bigger than what we’ve seen so far. And with hot money leaving China as investors rush for safe havens, and weakening exports exacerbating the liquidity drain, there seems to be little that can be done at the moment to reverse falling property prices. Exports and property are currently the biggest drivers of Chinese growth. While I expect infrastructure construction will pick up, fiscal stimuli simply can’t offset the impact of a fall in these two markets. China’s 2009 growth rate will likely reach a 10-year low.

What about America’s USD 700 billion bailout package? The package may stabilize the financial system, i.e., save large financial institutions from bankruptcy, but it won’t stimulate lending and keep the real economy afloat. In Anglo-Saxon economies, consumer lending, built on rising property values, sustained a prolonged consumption boom. With property prices falling, it’s hard to imagine households wanting to borrow, let alone banks actually giving them the money. The USD 700 billion is likely to sit on the banks’ balance sheets, not return to the real economy.

Central banks around the world cut interest rates last month, despite high inflation, hoping to boost demand. This will, in all likelihood, merely lead to greater inflation. Rate cuts stimulate demand by encouraging borrowing, but they can’t work magic. With household balance sheets so damaged, credit demand will only return when households are again on a sound footing.

Weak demand, however, won’t erase inflation. First, energy and food prices remain elevated due to supply and demand issues – demand in the ex-Soviet bloc is rising rather than falling, and demand among oil exporting countries is especially strong. Second, manufacturing prices won’t fall. Ten years ago, as multinationals moved factories from developed economies to China, prices converged towards China’s production costs. But, now China’s costs are rising, and its production capacity is shrinking, both of which will cause prices to rise. Third, IT is fully integrated into production costs.

The dollar rallied over the past month, bringing it back to center stage in traders’ consciousness. The Australian dollar (AUD) and the euro are down 15% against it, the pound sterling down by half as much. It isn’t yet anything to get excited about though. The dollar’s bounce is due to the unwinding of carry trades. The rapid appreciation of the yen against the AUD, for example, is due to high interest rates in Australia attracting even retail investors who borrowed yen at 0.5% interest and bought the Australian dollar at 7%. When Australia cut its interest rate, the carry trades were unwound quickly, and the AUD tumbled.

The dollar’s strength has also had a big impact on commodity prices. Many speculators have invested heavily in the “long commodities and short dollar” trade. As the dollar strengthened, they unwound their positions in commodities too, causing prices to tumble. As I argued above, though, the constraints on the supply side and demand in emerging economies will favor high energy and agriculture prices for years to come.

As the technical factors run their course, speculators will come back into energy and gold. Real interest rates are already negative, and rate cuts could accentuate this. With paper currency depreciating in real value, it is rational for investors to buy value-preserving commodities like energy and gold. The bullish story for energy and gold may last for a decade. Of course, they will fluctuate, as the current trend demonstrates. But they will remain good assets in an era of inflation.

The dollar’s strength will continue for three to six months. As the US economy slows, so will its imports. The trade deficit may fall quickly enough to strengthen the dollar further, but monetary loosening measures will come back to bite later. The US Federal Reserve (Fed) cares more about the economy than inflation. Indeed, when the market shifts its attention to the ballooning debts of the Federal government, the dollar could have a bigger crisis than the last one.

In addition to bailouts and rate cuts, more radical measures are coming. The Fed is already talking about buying commercial papers that businesses issue. The market for commercial papers is pretty much dead now. The risk premium as priced in a credit default swap market is far too high for businesses to function normally. If the Fed purchases the papers directly, it is essentially lending to a business at a risk premium that wouldn’t be touched on the open market. Investors don’t trust these businesses, because they can’t understand their balance sheets. The Fed would use taxpayer money to take on this risk.

Also, central banks could buy government bonds to monetize national debts. With the US’ budget deficit likely to be 4% of GDP in 2008 and an astonishing 6% of GDP in 2009 — without counting the bailout costs — it may have to issue USD 3 trillion of new papers into the Treasury market. If the market cannot absorb this, and the Fed steps in to buy, it is equivalent to printing money to fund fiscal spending.

When it comes to the “inflation or deflation” debate, we should consider who Fed chairman Ben Bernanke is. He has spent his lifetime researching ways to stop deflation, i.e., finding new ways to print money. When push comes to shove, he will do anything to stop deflation. With Bernanke at the helm of the Fed, we should worry about inflation, not deflation.

The creative monetary measures ahead could stabilize the business sector, but won’t prevent a recession. Households first need to decrease leverage if they’re going to take out further debt. The total wealth in the world may have declined by USD 15 trillion. A similar amount could be lost in the next 12 months. It is not possible to get consumers spending again with wealth destruction of such magnitude.

After the recession, I don’t see how the global economy can resume robust growth quickly. Debt-driven Anglo-Saxon consumption has powered the global economy for years. But, after the fallout, investors are unlikely to make the same mistake twice. Most people have long memories.”

21 comments:

Nick von Mises said...

Interesting but the guy can't get over the normal inflationista hurdles. He's also weird to suggest bailouts are PREVENTING things from being worse.

He's also rather down on the Anglo-Saxon economies even though all the current evidence suggests it's EVERYBODY ELSE who's in the biggest trouble.

Anonymous said...

I'm going to say here what I told some co-workers today. There are three truths about China:

1) Communist governments running planned economies can't pretend to be good capitalists and succeed at it.

2) Any economy based on manufacturing inferior goods at low cost to sell to consumer economies on credit is going to fail, and fail hard when a deflationary credit bubble pops.

3) The Chinese need to be more concerned about the social fabric of their country right now more than underwriting 8% GDP growth through currency and economic manipulation. When people don't eat, they get desperate and when their government fails them, they become angry. This is a bad combination of factors.

The last thing on my list is that I don't trust China to behave rationally when push comes to shove. I believe they will begin dumping treasuries and as a consequence, rates on (especially) the 10 year could rise by 100 to 150 basis points quickly. This would just pour more salt into the credit market wounds and prolong this economic nuclear winter by 2 to 3 years.

Anonymous said...

nick perhaps you have highlighted the black swan the very idea that the US created this shitstorm and is seen as benefiting the most will creat the black storm. count on it

Anonymous said...

Anyone registered on Karls Market Ticker blog? I'm not and can't write comment. If someone here is feel free to place this comment for all of us amateurs out here. Karls liquidity trap post today talks of the bid/cover ratio this time being very low at 0.08. People there were asking how this compares to "normal" times. Using the link he provides to the fed, a link to "2008 Monatary Policy Releases" at the bottom of that page takes one to 2008 Fed releases where there are numerous "Fed announces results of auction..." Some with different amounts and times, but a similar one was Oct 21 with ratio of 0.76 vs 0.08 now and bidders then 74 vs 16 now. The earliest shown has Jan 15 has ratio of 1.85 and 56 bidders.

Thanks again for great posts, info, and comments from all you knowledgable folks.

Brant, Atlanta, GA

Anonymous said...

as milton friedman and anna schwartz so ably showed, history says that inflation is always a monetary phenomenon. this is part of my thought process and as such i agree with the analysis here of Berstanky and the merry gangsters, and the inflation likely to follow. but, i am struggling to understand why japan, after 20+ years of zero rates, plus quantitative easing, did not stoke big-time inflation....any thoughts out there

Unknown said...

Inflation = when you have money that are not covering your goods
Deflation = your goods are exceeding the money supply

If a central bank is printing money without a real cover in real economy then what i happening are the following :
- everybody will pay differentiated this black hole
- those who have a good backup (sindicates, lobby etc) are winning as always
- the rest will pay it harder (usualy the average employee by sheer work) - meaning that they will require government assistance (this is like the marriage - in couple you solve the issues that you wouldn't have first place :) - but hey is a cheerfull world :) )

If this kind of inflation has added interest which usually has - then the bubble is doubled :)

The shit we are going to live in my opinion is like this :
- the average American stops spending
- all the major exporters of the world which are based on us clients will bite the dust (as the author said)

The future is energy and food industry for most and innovation for the rest (most europeans understood this for 10 years ago).

Anonymous said...

baskets puma future cat low engine noirBon March¨¦ Chaussure Sports Shop:puma future low catChaussure Puma Femme,Chaussure Puma Homme,Chaussure Nike Femme,Chaussure Nike homme,future cat low engineChaussure Sport et plus. Livraison Rapide.Paypal

Anonymous said...

http://delii.blog.drecom.jp/
http://ameblo.jp/nikeairshoes
http://eretertyt.cocolog-nifty.com/blog/

Anonymous said...

chaussures homme
chaussures homme nike
chaussures homme pas cher
achat chaussures homme

Unknown said...

spyder
coats & jackets
leather jacket
ski jacket
the north face
moncler
coach outlet
coach handbags
coach bags
Moncler
Moncler jackets
moncler outlet
Coat&Jaclets
Spyder Jackets
Spyder Jackets
MBT shoes
MBT footwear
Moncler
Moncler jackets
Moncler coats
coach outlet
coach handbag
coach bag
spyder

titaniumjewelry said...

Titanium Jewelry is becoming more and more popular in the world. It is healthy for everybody. Titanium Jewelry contains many kinds of styles such as Mens Jewellery , Womens Titanium Jewelry , couple Titanium Jewelry and others. Of course Mens Titanium Jewelry includes Mens Cufflinks , Mens Rings , Titanium Rings For Men , Mens Pendants & Necklaces , Mens Earrings , Mens Bracelets. And Womens Titanium Jewelry also includes Womens Earrings , Womens Necklaces , Womens Bracelets. Our Titanium Jewelry online store offer you fashion and beautiful jewelry. The price is up to 40% off and all free shipping. If you want to wear the jewelry according to your image. Welcome to visit our website http://www.titanium-jewelry-online.com/

New nike soccer shoes said...

I like football, prefer the beautiful and stylish football shoes to introduce New nike soccer shoes.

Unknown said...

2011 Uggs clearance you to Own Suede Tall Boots,the genuine sheepskin and lightweight sole bring the warm and relief feeling to you,Ugg Australia Boots online store for you to Buy excellent one to adjust to meet your shape of your feet, much sale price in Uggs nederland online for you Enjoy!UGGS are also in all size that will fit every member of your family both from the very young to the very old. Although you may have no difficulty in finding the perfect size boot for you, you may have difficulty in deciding what color you want. In this paragraph of snow ugg australia boots are very ladies like. This type of boots have prevent slippery, warm and wear-resisting function. Especially in the cold winter, can be Ugg outlet store sudden them out to keep warm and comfortable characteristics. They are your best companion in winter.


Cheap Moncler Online Shop is very modest,because the discount Moncler Outlet Store,can help you grasp the beauty of a woman's eye,you collect a lot of online Moncler Boots,your whole world seems warm and stylish.In the winter,Womens Moncler always seize the audience's attention,there is no beautiful style,both warm and comfortable,classic. Moncler sale Therefore,the soft winter fashion discount Moncler Online become the first choice and a single product.Moncler 2011 will not let you down for sure. Our Moncler Outlet Store presents many different products.

Anonymous said...

To be Nike Mercurial Vapor Superfly capable of convey more persons eyes, the Nike Mercurial Superfly quantity of Nike designer Nike football boots the advanced technology and fashion elements Nike mercurial vapor within the trend. We're able to uncover these Nike mercurial vapor fg excellent sports have fashion styles, dazzling coloring ways, high quality. Nike vapor soccer shoes While despite the fact that Nike Football Cleats may be the well-known brand on the planet, the company still concerned human medical insurance and luxury more than profits. Best Soccer Cleats Whichever type of sports footwear of Nike, the company always strictly demand designers to create is totally safe sport footwear to make certain that gamers is capable of doing maximum effect within the match. Nike mercurial vapor superfly iii Putting on such designer Best Soccer Cleats, you will find that all footwear transmit the great comfortable feeling for the feet, and may reduce the foot burden totally. Anyway, Nike designer Football Cleats is extremely perfect Nike football boots for everybody in daily existence.

muebles valladolid said...

It cannot truly have success, I believe so.

www.crearpaginaweb.com said...

The writer is totally fair, and there's no doubt.

camobel said...

I consider everyone must read this.

cameo zhang said...

The planet PANDORA charms cheap ( space ) A new Track record
The planet pandora is renowned for it really is graceful overlook towards old classic elegance pendant (offered found in Late 90s). And yet lurking behind his or her path becoming a world-renowned rings clients are a painless report of one\'s Danish goldsmith with the exceptional lady eager to show the efforts considering the environment.

cameo zhang said...

For a way clearly these page, \"Addicted towards Charm just for Necklace and also Presently Exactly Looking for the best Charms\" ended up being gained I reckon it will be pretty sure there presently exist loads of you in that respect there concentrating on the same being addicted style recovering. For that reason, Let me proceed to solution that a great many of individuals give food an individual\'s desire by just amassing The planet Beads Pandora and charms. I will not pin the blame on most people, because you might and tothave

price per head online said...

Wow great post very informative, all i can add is if you would like to read more on the subject, you should visit google and find relevent sources! hope it is helpful

price per head call center said...

Thank you for the efforts you been putting on making your site such an interesting and informative place to browse through.