Custom Search

Friday, October 31, 2008

Japan Stuck, Quantitative Easing in the US

Yesterday’s post Closer to ZIRP, Liquidity Trap, Deflation was all about the US.

Consider this:

The Japanese are still stuck in ZIRP… in the same liquidity trap… and still alternating between mild inflation and mild deflation.

Bank of Japan Cuts Rate to 0.3% to Fend Off Prolonged Recession: “The Bank of Japan cut its benchmark interest rate to 0.3 percent to help stave off a prolonged recession.

Governor Masaaki Shirakawa cast the deciding vote to lower the key overnight lending rate from 0.5 percent after four of the eight board members dissented, the central bank said in Tokyo today. Three wanted to cut the rate to 0.25 percent, and one voted to leave it unchanged, Shirakawa said.

Shirakawa, 59, came under pressure to lower borrowing costs for the first time in seven years after the Nikkei 225 Stock Average slumped to the lowest level since 1982 on concern that the global financial rout would deepen Japan's downturn. Until today, the bank had kept rates unchanged in the face of cuts by counterparts worldwide, arguing they were already “very low.”

A rate cut will probably do little to prop up the economy; nevertheless the bank was probably fearful they'd be viewed as clinging to an overly rigid stance in the middle of a global crisis” if they didn't move, said Teizo Taya, a former Bank of Japan board member who now advises the Daiwa Institute of Research.””

Those of you that mistakenly think the ‘liquidity’ the central banks are injecting will result in a hyper inflationary explosion, think again. The Bank of Japan (BOJ) employed everything including quantitative easing in a desperate attempt to re-flate and got NOTHING.

“Inflation will evaporate next fiscal year, the bank said. Core consumer prices will rise 1.6 percent in the current fiscal year and fail to increase in the following 12 months, it said. Prices will gain 0.3 percent in the year starting April 2010.”

Ben Bernanke is already employing the exact same strategies. The various liquidity facilities are the very mechanisms that implement quantitative easing. The interview below sheds light on how the BOJ did it. Already the similarities are clear.


Tomoya Masanao Discusses the End of Japan's Quantitative Easing:

In March 2001, the Bank of Japan (BoJ) began an historic new monetary policy known as “quantitative easing” in an effort to revive Japan’s economy and end the deflationary decline in consumer prices. Five years later, on March 9, the BoJ ended the quantitative easing policy, satisfied that the Japanese economy was on the path to stable, reflationary growth. In the interview below, Tomoya Masanao, PIMCO’s head of portfolio management in Tokyo, discusses why the BoJ ended quantitative easing and what he expects for the future.

Q: What did the Bank of Japan’s “quantitative easing” policy entail?

Masanao: In setting monetary policy, central banks normally target a specific short-term interest rate, such as the Fed funds rate in the U.S or the uncollateralized overnight call rate in Japan. The central bank sets a target level for the interest rate and then controls it on a daily basis, injecting money into the financial system or withdrawing money from the system as needed to keep the interest rate at the targeted level.

Under quantitative easing, the BoJ stopped targeting the level of the overnight call rate, which had already been lowered to zero in an effort to end deflation and stimulate the Japanese economy. Instead, the BoJ set the level of its current account as the operating target and raised the target level of its current account to $250 to $300 billion, which was far in excess of the roughly $40 billion level needed when the operating target was the overnight call rate at zero percent.

Operationally, the quantitative easing policy required the BoJ to purchase trillions of yen of financial securities, including about $120 billion per year of Japanese government bonds in an operation known as “Rinban.” The BoJ also purchased asset-backed securities and equities, and extended the terms of its commercial bill purchasing operation up to 12 months. The combined effect of these operations was to effectively flood the Japanese financial system with excess liquidity.

The BoJ also explicitly pre-committed to maintain the quantitative easing regime at least until year-on-year changes in the consumer price index excluding fresh foods (the core CPI) became positive in a stable manner. With quantitative easing tied to the core CPI, the BoJ’s explicit commitment to its policy regime was much stronger than the Fed’s commitment to maintain easy monetary policy for a “considerable period” or its commitment to being “patient” in raising rates.

Q: Why did the BoJ decide at the March 8-9 meeting to end the quantitative easing policy?

Masanao: Quantitative easing worked; the Japanese economy is recovering and core consumer prices are rising. Before the BoJ’s March meeting, the year-on-year change in Japan’s core CPI had been positive for three consecutive months, and the core CPI has now increased for four consecutive months. Most importantly, BoJ policymakers expect a sustained recovery and continued increases in core consumer prices, fulfilling the conditions laid out in the commitment to maintain quantitative easing.

Q: How did the quantitative easing policy help to revive Japan’s economy?

Masanao: The BoJ’s pre-commitment to quantitative easing was an important element of the policy’s success. The market was able to expect that the BoJ’s zero interest rate policy would continue for months or even years by just looking at core CPI prints, allowing not only money market rates but also two-year and even longer rates to stay close to zero. The effect of the BoJ’s pre-commitment strategy was also evident in stabilizing the banking system and tightening credit market spreads in general. The availability of term financing at a level close to overnight financing rates enhanced borrowers’ credit. In other words, the quantitative easing policy made easy money available for many borrowers in Japan.

Excess liquidity in the financial system was another key element of the quantitative easing policy. The BoJ officially downplays the role of excess liquidity, concluding that excess liquidity only helped to stabilize the banking system and did not stimulate the economy. I doubt this conclusion.

It is true that bank lending did not improve until recently despite the excess liquidity provided by the BoJ. But bank lending did finally improve. It just took a long time for excess liquidity to work because the banking system was weak and the corporate sector was busy cleaning up its balance sheet. The BoJ just needed to wait for the banking sector to become healthier before the liquidity started to work.

I also believe that assets that the BoJ purchased in large size, i.e., money market instruments and JGBs, benefited by reducing their risk premium. Simply put, when the central bank becomes a large buyer of specific assets as a non-economic agent, supply of those assets to the private sector is smaller than it otherwise would be.

Altogether, the recovery in the banking system, the sustained low rates and the reduction in risk premiums have led to rising business activity and investment. In turn, the expansion in the corporate sector is driving real wages higher, supporting the consumer sector. External demand from the U.S. and China also aided Japan’s recovery, but the BoJ’s quantitative easing policy played a large role in helping to stimulate internal demand.

Q: What do you expect from the BoJ now that the central bank has ended quantitative easing?

Masanao: With the end of quantitative easing, the BoJ’s policy framework will be less transparent but more flexible. The BoJ shifted gears back to targeting the overnight call rate and will need to substantially reduce excess liquidity in its current account to around $40 billion before starting to hike policy rates from the current zero percent. The outright purchase of Japanese government bonds under the Rinban program will also have to be scaled back at some stage in the future.

Future policy decisions will now be based on two perspectives the BoJ recently outlined. The first perspective is the outlook for prices and economic activity one to two years into the future, with an “understanding” that medium- to long-term price stability means an inflation rate of 0% to 2%. The second perspective is an examination of longer-term risks that are most relevant to monetary policy aimed at generating sustainable growth with price stability.

This two-perspective framework is both good news and bad news. The good news is that the new framework will give the BoJ flexibility in monetary policy that is based on an “understanding,” not a “target,” of price stability, while still ensuring some degree of transparency. The bad news is that the BoJ may end up tightening monetary policy too early, and by too much, under the new framework.

Q: Why do you worry the BoJ might tighten too much and too soon?

Masanao: I have three concerns. First, I think the 0% to 2% range for the inflation rate is too low. The lower the level of price stability is, the faster the BoJ is likely to hike rates to prevent inflation risks.

Second, when addressing a forward-looking approach, the BoJ already seems too concerned about an asset price bubble at this stage. Right after the end of quantitative easing, the BoJ released a document titled, “The Bank’s Thinking on Price Stability,” that explained the lagged effect monetary policy has on general prices and detailed the Bank’s own experience during Japan’s asset price bubble in the late 1980s. I think this illustrates that the asset bubble that arose during the 1980s and then popped, leading to the long period of stagnation in Japan’s economy, remains a traumatic experience for the BoJ. It is true that land prices have already seen double-digit growth in primary areas of the large cities in Japan. But I think it is way too early to worry about an asset price bubble and its future negative impact on the real economy.

And third, the BoJ does not believe that its outright purchase of Japanese government bonds under the Rinban operation had an impact in reducing risk premiums in long-term bonds, which suggests that the Rinban operation may be scaled back sooner than later. I worry that the BoJ might be overconfident in downplaying the role of the Rinban. The Japanese government bond market, unfortunately, is much too spoiled to properly function without the BoJ’s kindness as the “buyer of last resort.”

But I still trust that the BoJ took as the most significant lesson of the last decade that the risk for the central banks is extremely asymmetric when the economy is only at mild inflation or disinflation. More than any other central bank, the BoJ understands the lack of policy tools that are immediately effective when the economy slips into deflation. Japan’s economy is no doubt recovering. But it is only just emerging from deflation. Let’s not forget it.

Q: Thank you, Tomoya, we look forward to speaking with you again as the BoJ’s new policy regime develops.

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

baskets puma future cat low engine noirBon March¨¦ Chaussure Sports Shop:puma future low catChaussure Puma Femme,Chaussure Puma Homme,Chaussure Nike Femme,Chaussure Nike homme,future cat low engineChaussure Sport et plus. Livraison Rapide.Paypalle

Anonymous said...

sliherve leger
herve leger dresses

chanel
chanel iman
chanel outlet
chanel handbag
Chanel Wallet
Chanel Watch
chanel purse

Chanel Sunglasses
chanel bags
chanel earrings
chanel jewelry
chanel shoes

Anonymous said...

ghd
cheap ghd
ghd straighteners
Benefit GHD
GHD IV Salon Styler
GHD MINI STYLER
GHD Precious gift
Gold GHD
Kiss GHD
New pink GHD
Pink GHD
Pure Black GHD
Pure White GHD
Purple GHD
Rare GHD
Babyliss
polo boots
polo shoes
cheap straighteners
ghd hair straighteners
hair straighteners
Purple GHD IV Styler
Pure White GHD
Pure Black GHD
Pink GHD IV Styler
Kiss GHD Styler
Gray GHD IV Styler
Gold GHD IV Styler
GHD Rare Styler
GHD IV Salon Styler
Black GHD IV Styler
Benefit GHD IV Styler

Unknown said...

ankh royalty

ankhroyalty

ankh royalty clothing

ankh royalty sweats

ankh royalty tracksuits
babyliss
babyliss pro
babyliss hair
babyliss i trim
babyliss flat iron
babyliss you curl
babyliss hair straighteners
babyliss hair straightener
babyliss straightener
babyliss straighteners
babyliss portability
babyliss straightening irons
babyliss hair iron
babyliss straightening iron

Unknown said...

Armani Sunglasses
Burberry Sunglasses
Cartier Sunglasses
Chanel Sunglasses
Coach Sunglasses
D&G Sunglasses
Dior Sunglasses
ED Hardy Sunglasses
Fendi Sunglasses
LV Sunglasses
Oakley Sunglasses
Police Sunglasses
Ray Ban Sunglasses
Roberto Cavalli Sunglasses
Versace Sunglasses
cheap gucci sunglasses
cheap prada sunglasses
cheap D&G sunglasses
discount gucci sunglasses
discount prada sunglasses
discotunt D&G sunglasses
cheap oaklay sunglasses
discount oaklay sunglasses
sunglasses outlet
air max,Nike air max
air max 90
nike air max 90
air max 1
air max 95
nike air max 360
nike air max ltd
air max ltd
air max 360
air max classic,Air Max Huarache

love-up-you said...

Die Zeitmessung hat ein Ziel des Menschen von thomas sabo online Anfang an und eine Zeitleiste wurde Ihnen beim Verständnis helfen, wie wir wo sind wir mit Uhren bekam. Uhren haben so viele neue thomas sabo schmuck günstig Funktionen. Sie haben das Datum, die Zeit, mal über Zeitzonen hinweg, und angebote thomas sabo einige haben Stoppuhren. Die meisten Uhren haben eine Art von Alarm in ihnen. Die Möglichkeiten sind unbegrenzt und anhänger kette ich kann wirklich einen Dick Tracy Art zu sehen sein echt.Hier eine Chronologie der Geschichte zu sehen. Einige kette thomas sabo der Jahre möglicherweise nicht in chronologischer Reihenfolge aufgeführt werden, aber ich habe sie so nah wie thomas sabo kette möglich. Es ist sehr interessant zu erfahren, wie Uhren entwickelt haben. Es ist erstaunlich, wenn ich an den Köpfen der Menschen, die ihre Hand bei der Schaffung von Uhren, wie klug und schmuck thomas sabo ketten technische sie gewesen sein musste denken!Vor Das Hauptproblem war die thomas sabo ohrschmuck treibende Kraft der Uhren liefen wurden Gewichtungen. Dies machte es angebote thomas sabo ohrschmuck schwierig, sie herumtragen. Henlien war fünfzehn Gulden für eine vergoldete Moschus-Apfel thomas sabo ohrringe mit einer Uhr gezahlt.

contactos en valencia said...

Well, I do not actually imagine it is likely to have effect.

Unknown said...

2011 Uggs clearance you to Own Suede Tall Boots,the genuine sheepskin and lightweight sole bring the warm and relief feeling to you,Ugg Australia Boots online store for you to Buy excellent one to adjust to meet your shape of your feet, much sale price in Uggs nederland online for you Enjoy!UGGS are also in all size that will fit every member of your family both from the very young to the very old. Although you may have no difficulty in finding the perfect size boot for you, you may have difficulty in deciding what color you want. In this paragraph of snow ugg australia boots are very ladies like. This type of boots have prevent slippery, warm and wear-resisting function. Especially in the cold winter, can be Ugg outlet store sudden them out to keep warm and comfortable characteristics. They are your best companion in winter.


Cheap Moncler Online Shop is very modest,because the discount Moncler Outlet Store,can help you grasp the beauty of a woman's eye,you collect a lot of online Moncler Boots,your whole world seems warm and stylish.In the winter,Womens Moncler always seize the audience's attention,there is no beautiful style,both warm and comfortable,classic. Moncler sale Therefore,the soft winter fashion discount Moncler Online become the first choice and a single product.Moncler 2011 will not let you down for sure. Our Moncler Outlet Store presents many different products.

Hermes Handbags said...

Hermes Scarf
Hermes Jypsiere
Hermes Constance
Hermes Victoria
Hermes Lindy
hermes evelyne
hermes garden party
hermes necklace
hermes 2011

Christian Louboutin Boots said...

Christian Louboutin Rolando
Christian Louboutin Sneakers
Christian Louboutin Evening
Christian Louboutin Wedges
Christian Louboutin Sandals
Christian Louboutin Boots
Christian Louboutin Slingback
Christian Louboutin Long Boots
Louboutin Ankle Boots

UGG Australia said...

UGG Roxy
UGG Sandals
UGG Slippers
UGG Suburb Crochet
UGG Suede
UGG Sundance
UGG Crochet
UGG Stripe
UGG Ultimate Bind
UGG Ultra
UGG Upside
UGG Dakota

muebles navalcarnero said...

Very effective material, thank you for this post.

Unknown said...

They furnish apart from Uggs on clearance but gadgets such as carriers, uggs clearance, scarf’s for example. quite numerous individuals produced carriers getting premium great residence leather-based which regularly do not spoil merely on top of that to mineral consuming water cannot bury in that dude or girls thinking about which they are mineral consuming water explanation carriers. Moncler Outlet Store  You can acquire scarfs getting premium great products within of a assortment of colorings on top of that to behaviour you previously viewed; they are steering to obtain entry to kinds cardstock hearts. Moncler shoes and boots will most possibly properly meets in your foot or so on top of that to preserve these individuals ease on top of that to exempt from anxiety. Moncler jackets typically are completely hip on top of that to ease.Moncler accouterment has obtained abounding modified appear as well as artist pockets quickly after which vests by method of which consist of Moncler Quincy, Moncler Outlet Online just for grownup males find out oneself anorak and consequently for. fundamentally every solitary and every solitary and every bottom appears has obtained proper function. For that aim of gentlemen covering up jerkin, lots of beneficial accouchement searching for for food to ensure which you can surviving as an angel within themoncler snow profit developed bogie expertise, countless individuals toon to acquire a magician. Moncler sale getting a result, countless of us genuinely should to them actualize your satisfactory aura and types of problems, in acquire which ordinarily accouchement abide not accountable and beautiful, delightful the delighted youth.Moncler dunkle Moncler Online Shop gentlemen alongside Purposes signifies just about everywhere concerning men’s standard. That cast for add-on gotten unique layouts to match up your must select on, Uggs clearance steady bottomward apparel, down-hat pockets, destruction moncler you desire, that is why the subsequent one specific grew to possess the Uggs nederland ability to flip out for getting for this Uggs clearance aim well-known.

cameo zhang said...

The planet PANDORA charms cheap ( space ) A new Track record
The planet pandora is renowned for it really is graceful overlook towards old classic elegance pendant (offered found in Late 90s). And yet lurking behind his or her path becoming a world-renowned rings clients are a painless report of one\'s Danish goldsmith with the exceptional lady eager to show the efforts considering the environment.

cameo zhang said...

For a way clearly these page, \"Addicted towards Charm just for Necklace and also Presently Exactly Looking for the best Charms\" ended up being gained I reckon it will be pretty sure there presently exist loads of you in that respect there concentrating on the same being addicted style recovering. For that reason, Let me proceed to solution that a great many of individuals give food an individual\'s desire by just amassing The planet Beads Pandora and charms. I will not pin the blame on most people, because you might and